I'll begin with the construction. It strongly resembles Garrett's ProPointer, the gold standard in the handheld pointer market. The hard plastic exterior seems robust, and should hold up well. For accessories, it comes with a fairly standard belt holster, four "tip caps" (more on these later), and a coiled lanyard. The lanyard seems like a great idea, but I didn't use it for this review, and I'll tell you why. Although the keychain rings on the lanyard are metal, the snap-clip is a pretty chintzy feeling plastic. It was the only part of the packaging that I felt appeared weak, and since I was using Keith's pinpointer, I didn't want to break it and left the lanyard at the truck. I will probably replace it with a sturdier clip at some point.
We spent a day out detecting at two different sites, one with good non-mineralized soil, and the second that I would describe as moderate to high mineralization. The number one catch phrase that caught my attention about the X-Pointer was - "I can't get it to false!" And I will give that statement a qualified "true." As far as pushing, twisting, scraping the pinpointer in the hole, I absolutely could NOT get it to false. Not a chirp. Remember those tip caps I told you about? At first I thought they were a neat but unnecessary add on. After using it for a day, I can see why they were included. Since it doesn't false from pressure, you really can use the pinpointer to scratch around in the dirt with pretty good force. That's probably what most impressed me from the X-Pointer, and I really feel it's what makes this unit a step above the competition.
Now I did say that "I can't get it to false" was true to a certain point, and here's the limitation. The X-Pointer is fairly unique in that it's a pulse induction pinpointer, and that would lend one to believe that it would be unaffected by ground mineralization. I didn't find that to be the case. While the unit worked great in the neutral field on full sensitivity, the hot-ground field would still cause some falsing on just clay. The falsing was worst when more of the shaft was in contact with the dirt, rather than just the tip. I tried the "ground balancing" technique that I use with my Garrett ProPointer, and the result was the same - the falsing went away, but took with it much of the depth and sensitivity. Unlike the ProPointer, however, the X-Pointer offers another solution. I simply turned the sensitivity level down from four (max) to two in the hot-ground field, and voila! No more falsing. The depth decreased a little from the maximum setting, but not nearly the same extent as when ground balanced. So again, one more point in the X-Pointer's column.
Alright now lets get down to brass tacks. Retail price? $89.00. Compare that to the $130-ish for the Garret, and even more for the Minelab. Wow. Enough said.
To recap - Doesn't false from pressure for extreme use. Adjustable sensitivity for hot ground. Easy to use. Depth comparable to the others on the market. And a better price. The ONLY question mark remaining is the longevity, and that we'll have to wait to see. So for now, I'm sold on the X-Pointer. It would make a great addition to any detectorists arsenal, and my first recommendation for new hobbyists. Well done, Deteknix, and thank you for a great product that I look forward to using as my primary handheld unit for years to come. If you're so inclined, head on over to Fort Bedford and pick up one for yourself.
What about a warranty??? Garrett has a 2 year warranty and great customer service,
ReplyDeleteThanks for bringing that up! The X-Pointer also comes with a 2 year warranty. I will agree that Garrett has a reputation for *extremely* good customer service! The flip side of that coin is that many ProPointer users are familiar with that customer service from having to send in falsing pointers. I'm not knocking Garrett, I still love them as a company and their ProPointer. We'll just have to wait and see how the X-Pointer holds up over time, and how they handle any issues that may crop up.
DeleteThanks for the comment!
I just recently had to send one in to get it replaced. I used it for two weekends. It was working great, and then it just stopped working. The positive battery connection had broke off and was rattling around inside. I promptly received an email after I sent one explaining the situation. They said that some of the units have been having this issue, and would send me a new one after receiving the old one. I sent it in to the service center address that was given to me in the email from http://warranty.golddiggermetaldetectors.com/ I mailed the detector on Tuesday the 9th and it arrived there on the 11th. I haven't heard back about it. I hope that the new one comes quick, the Bounty Hunter Pinpointer is almost unbearable to use after using the X Pointer. I wish they would send a quick email saying that they received the bad one and that they are sending a new one. Other than that, their service is great so far. I will post an update when I either hear back from them or receive the new one.
DeleteThanks,
Mike
I've got 3 Garrett Pro pointers and they are, as you've noted, the gold standard. I have noticed the issue with false signals when pressure is applied. This new model looks quite interesting and I'll give it a try when I need a new one. Something I find hard to understand though - why won't Garrett (or anyone for that matter) come out with a truly waterproof pointer for river and ocean detecting? They'd have an instant bestseller. Someone's not listening.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the great review.
Informative and really likable post. thanks for sharing.Gold Detector Dubai|Detech metal Detectors|Garrett handheld Metal Detector
ReplyDelete